This Mexican film (in Spanish) has it all when it comes to Cannibal Studies. When we discuss cannibalism, we think of sacrificial rituals, or people starving, or maybe just psychogenic appetites – some inner appetite that can only be satiated with human flesh. In most cannibal films, the cannibals are minor personalities, indistinct threats to the protagonist, not the main characters.
Welcome to We Are What We Are. A family of cannibals survive on human flesh, which is harvested by the father in bloody ritual ceremonies. When Dad dies, how are they to carry on? This is a family much like the one in The Texas Chain Saw Massacre: poor, disenfranchised, living on the edge of a consumer society from which they seem excluded.
Shot in Mexico city, the film reflects the struggle for survival in what some call a dog-eat-dog world, which of course is far more accurately a human-eat-human world, since we are often far nicer to dogs than to each other.
Yep, and the boys, Alfredo and his younger, vicious brother Julián, have been evicted from their market stall because Dad didn’t pay the rent. He was a watchmaker by trade, and also a procurer of human flesh. Kept the family fed. No more though. The boys have to take over.
Meanwhile, the coroner calls in the police. He has found something interesting in Dad’s stomach.
The police are not interested though. They don’t bother with cold cases. Or hot ones either, apparently. The coroner tells them
“In the reports, they blame the rats, but what about the two-legged kind?”
The boys head to the bridge, where the homeless children live. Self-service and easy to carry. This is not too far-fetched – there are many reports of death squads picking up kids and turning them over to drug cartels. But these boys have a different purpose, and they are not very good at it – the kids fight them off.
A cannibal fail. Their mother is furious because they put the family at risk. “Next we start trembling, because we’re going to die.”
Luckily, Sabina, the sister, has an idea.
Mexico City is presented as corrupt, steamy and full of predators. No cannibal need go hungry, with the streets full of homeless children and prostitutes. But these aren’t any old hungry or depraved cannibals (although they’re getting there fast) – they have a ritual, and prostitutes apparently just won’t do, so Mum beats her to death with a shovel.
The poor and desperate usually stalk their own. The family has tried the outcast children under the bridge, then the vulnerable prostitutes; now Alfredo follows a group of young gays to an underground club and picks up a young man, who tells him, without irony,
Alfredo is devastated by his first gay kiss. Well, we knew, he is so sensitive, while Julián is the one filled with carnivorous virility, and is quite straight, although incestuously drawn to his sister.
All taboos are out on the table here, just like the prostitute’s corpse.
Mother and Julián take the prostitute’s body back to the street where they found her, and Mum abuses the girls for wanting to fuck her sons.
On the hierarchy of monsters, she seems to consider cannibals rather higher than whores.
Alfredo brings his new boyfriend home, for dinner, as it were. But Julián is not impressed. Nor is Mum, prompting Alfredo to ask why she hates him,
Is he talking gay or cannibal? Maybe the status of outcast is enough. You are considered less than human, and so can be hunted, killed, eaten.
Mum has brought another bloke home, and they kill him after a struggle. But Alfredo’s boyfriend, Gustavo has escaped, and found the police:
Meanwhile, the prostitutes are finding ways to motivate the cops to look into the murder of their colleague.
Everyone is eating everyone in this world. Mum and sister are starting “the ritual” with the corpse, which involves candles, meat hooks and sharp knives. Juicy crunching sounds, as they pull the carcass apart. Look, if this troubles you, don’t ever go into a butcher shop – the actions and sounds are the same. Except for the munching on raw flesh bit maybe.
OK, enough spoilers. It is a horror movie, so the rules say the monster must die, with the opportunity for resurrection (in case of a sequel). And in cannibal movies, there is the Wendigo factor: the bite of the cannibal turns the victim into a cannibal, much like the vampire legends.
Except there really are cannibals in our world, and they are not always eating flesh. There are many ways of eating the outcast.
The critics gave it 72% on Rotten Tomatoes, although the viewers were less generous.
The Los Angeles Times said it was
An unexpectedly rich exploration of family bonds, blood rituals and the oftentimes zombie-like desire to assume the roles proscribed to each of us.
The New York Post was similarly insightful
Grau’s script is intelligent, and it has something to say about family and social dysfunction. You just might want to skip meat for a few days.
3 thoughts on ““Every family has a secret recipe” – WE ARE WHAT WE ARE (Somos lo que hay), Grau, 2010.”
Pingback: Cannibal Dad: WE ARE WHAT WE ARE (Mickle, 2013) – The Cannibal Guy
Pingback: “This thirst is consuming me”: CRONOS (Guillermo del Toro, 1993) – The Cannibal Guy
Pingback: “We’re NOT Maori cannibals”, FRESH MEAT (Danny Mulheron, 2012) – The Cannibal Guy